Cindy Yes, you have to check in the comments to see why the book was returned to the validation pool. Sometimes even then, due to the cryptic nature of the comments, it takes a bit of guesswlwork trying to make heads or tails of exactly what is wanted but not supplied. I right now have one such book -- Boot Camp for Christians -- which has now been returned twice for a reason I cannot quite put 2 and 2 together on though, I'm certain, that an administrator clearly knows what is lacking.